Sections
Home » YES! Blogs » Shannon Hayes » Movies, My Kids, and Me

YES! I want to try YES!
Magazine.
YES! by Email
Join over 62,000 others already signed up for FREE YES! news.
[SAMPLE]  [ARCHIVE]
YES! This Week email logo
Sign up for our weekly highlights email. 

David Korten's Agenda for a New Economy: 3 Ways to Get the Book

Posters ad (generic)

Hot or Cold: the YES! Klean Kanteen

 

Movies, My Kids, and Me

Shannon Hayes used movies to give her daughters—and herself—an occasional break. Then they began to take over.

TV girl, image by Keirsten Balukas

Image by Keirsten Balukas

My youngest daughter’s full name is Ula Lockwood Hayes Hooper. But we’ve always called her Ula de la Luna. She was conceived and born by the light of the full moon, choosing to join the world by swimming out into a pool of water in a room lit solely by firelight and lunar reflections on the snow outside the windows. 

And the moon has always seemed to be her personal friend. It was one of the first words she learned, and she would ask for it before going to sleep at night. On summer nights I’d carry her out to the lawn to visit with it before bedtime, and in the winter we’d scramble around to all the windows to search it out, wave, and sing “Goodnight Moon!”

As I’ve suggested in earlier writings, Ula has always had a rather kinetic disposition—one that made it very difficult to leave her with grandparents to give Mommy and Daddy a respite, much less allow us a few moments of pre-dinner conversation before she would discover my kitchen knives, dump the houseplants, figure out if her dad had left out any power tools, or eat half a box of chalk. I vividly remember sitting with my head on the kitchen counter, whimpering in desperation to Bob: “When can we get this kid interested in movies?”

Television has never been part of our family. But movies have been another matter altogether. Bob loves them in all forms, I like them on occasion, and we both came to adore them for the parenting relief they offered when our oldest, Saoirse, was just a toddler. We felt that, since our kids weren’t seeing advertisements or watching a screen all day, an occasional movie when we needed it was perfectly acceptable. We showed Saoirse Sesame Street videos to help her learn her alphabet and numbers, and played and replayed Beauty and the Beast whenever we needed to have some quiet time for ourselves. 

Shannon Hayes, Photo by Bob Hooper.Meet the Radical Homemakers:
How families are achieving ecological, social and economic transformation...under their own roofs.

We tried Sesame Street with Ula.  She preferred pulling the cat’s tail. We tried Beauty and the Beast. After a few minutes, she toddled into the kitchen to experiment with putting pens and markers into the pencil sharpener, then asked to tour the windows in search of her moon. Then we tried Scooby Doo.

Ula forgot the moon.

The charisma of the Mystery, Inc. gang won over Ula’s heart. She assiduously perfected her impersonations of ghosts, mummies and vampires; studied and rehearsed Shaggy’s expressions, mastered his incessant use of the word “like,” and cultivated a dynamic Scooby voice. When the eye doctor told us Ula needed glasses, after many battles, we finally got her to experiment with lenses by purchasing oversized black frames so that she could look like Velma.

By her third birthday, Ula was fluent in Scooby Doo, and a few times each week, Bob and I had luxuries like folded laundry, complete conversations, glasses of wine by the fire, washed dishes, and even some time to listen to the radio. My knives stayed where I left them, the chalk went uneaten, the houseplants began to recover from their trauma.

Since we were homeschooling Saoirse, we expanded the movie repertoire. We showed the kids Magic School Bus videos, documentaries on bugs, and film versions of the literature we were reading as a family.

We never intended for movies to take over our lives. But it felt like they did, even if our kids spent far less time in front of a screen than most children. At first, it was something we allowed once per week. Then it became negotiable. Saoirse would find me as soon as Ula woke from her afternoon nap. “Can we watch a movie?” If I answered “no,” the nagging would ensue.  I’d argue for all the other evening pastimes we’d come to enjoy as a family:

We never intended for movies to take over our lives. But it felt like they did, even if our kids spent far less time in front of a screen than most children.

“Music night?” (This is when Bob plays the guitar and we sing).

“No.  I don’t want to do that.”

“Game night?”

“We’d rather watch a movie.”

“Popcorn and cider by the fire while I read to you?”

“How ‘bout popcorn and cider and a movie?”

By the end of last winter, Saoirse and Ula were pestering us for movies every night.  I told them I didn’t like the pestering.  I whined to Bob that I felt as though the kids wouldn’t talk to us after sunset, unless it was to ask for a movie. Together we warned them: The nagging had to stop, or the movies would go away.

The nagging didn’t stop. Once the girls settled in to watch yet another documentary showing how slugs mate, Bob would pour me a glass of wine, and we’d commiserate that it wasn’t the kids who were addicted to movies. It was us. We could threaten to take them away, but we were the ones who faced true punishment, because we’d lose our together time.

Then one afternoon this past spring, without planning, it happened. I went upstairs to wake Ula from her nap. Saoirse joined me. Ula opened her eyes and looked at me.

“Hi there, sleepy girl!”

“Can we watch a movie?” The first words out of her mouth?!

“No.” 

Saoirse joined her. “We’ll watch the Magic School Bus. It’s educational.”

Suddenly, I saw my cherubic, wholesome, earth-loving, home-schooled children with new eyes. They were brats.

“No. I want to play music tonight.”

“No,” came their unison reply. “Movie.”

“Then let’s play games.”

“Movie.”

“If you ask me again, I’m going to take it away.” Admittedly, I’d used that line before. I guess that’s why they ignored me.

“Movie!”  It was thrown at me as though I wasn’t to be taken seriously. Suddenly, I saw my cherubic, wholesome, earth-loving, home-schooled children with new eyes. They were brats.

“I’m done!”  I went over to the television and frantically began pulling wires out the back.

“NOOOOOOOO!!!”  They both screamed, tears flowing from their faces.  Bob, sitting in the kitchen, overheard the entire drama. He came upstairs. I thought he was going to stop me. To the contrary, he joined me in a frenzy of electronic disconnection while the girls carried on in hysterics as though we were shooting their dog.

Radical Homemakers Book Link

Radical Homemakers: Reclaiming Domesticity from a Consumer Culture

By Shannon Hayes
Left to Write Press, 2010, 300 pages, $23.95.
Support YES! when you buy here from an independent bookstore.

We left them in a caterwauling heap on the bed and went downstairs, where we sat to watch the sunset on the budding maple trees with deer-in-the-headlights expressions on our faces. As the mourning continued upstairs, we inventoried the full repercussions of our actions. No more cocktail hour. No more evening Internet. No more public radio news broadcasts. Taking away the movies suddenly seemed like a bigger commitment to parenting than conception, opting out of daycare, or choosing to homeschool.  Worried about how we’d survive, we decided to try it for the growing season to see how we fared.

It turned out taking away movies had bigger consequences than we realized. We found ourselves opting out of nights out, yoga classes—just about everything we could. But it wasn’t because we needed full-time home commitments to entertain our kids. It was because suddenly, we just didn’t want to be away from them. Admittedly, we don’t get anywhere near as many private conversations as we’d like, but we have discovered that our kids are really fun.  I’ve laughed more this summer than I have for years. Their fantasy play is more about scenes from their own imaginations, rather than re-creations of favorite movie plots. They run around  having naked water fights, linger over dinner conversation, ask to help in the kitchen. They play harder, to the point where they work themselves into a lather, and they seem to argue less. They make up songs, shake rattles, jingle bells and bang drums when we play music. They come up with their own knock-knock jokes (which are really funny in their non-sequitor un-funniness), and they dance.

We thought bedtime would come earlier with no movies in the house. To the contrary. We enjoy each other’s company so much at night, we all find it hard to wind down and climb up to bed. The sun is long set before any of us thinks of brushing our teeth.

Which means Ula sees her moon.

It was clear and beautiful the night of last month’s full moon. Bob and I were sitting out on the porch watching the fireflies when Ula came to join us. She sat on my lap, staring up into the sky, then turned to look up at me.

“Mommy, would you talk the moon?”

I tried to imagine how the silvery sheen would sound. Speaking in a hushed voice I said, “Why hello, Ula!”

Ula jumped off my lap, ran out to the lawn, and called up to the sky.

“Hello Moon!!!”

Hearing the commotion, Saoirse ran out of the house and joined her. “Hi Moon!”

For now, we are enjoying the thrill of our children’s unleashed imaginations, a spectacle far greater than the best film I’ve ever seen.

“How are you girls this evening?”

“Well, thank you!” They called out together.

“Moon,” said Ula, “if you sing, I’ll dance for you.”

I don’t remember what the moon sang, but it must have been a stirring melody, because the image from that evening stays in my mind as one I will hold until my dying day. Saoirse and Ula are on the lawn, twirling about under the light, looking as though they are floating in a fairy land, bathed in moon glow and surrounded by lightning bugs. Bob is with me on the porch, and we are smiling straight through to our souls. Maybe the movies will come back, every once in a while, when the snow flies. It’s hard to know. For now, we are enjoying the thrill of our children’s unleashed imaginations, a spectacle far greater than the best film I’ve ever seen.

After a good long while, the moon sings out,“I think it’s time for little girls to go to sleep.” Looking up, smiles across their faces, they wave their arms and both answer back, “Goodnight, Moon!”


Shannon HayesShannon Hayes wrote this article for YES! Magazine, a national, nonprofit media organization that fuses powerful ideas with practical actions. Shannon is the author of Radical Homemakers: Reclaiming Domesticity from a Consumer Culture, The Grassfed Gourmet and The Farmer and the Grill. She is the host of Grassfedcooking.com and RadicalHomemakers.com. Hayes works with her family on Sap Bush Hollow Farm in Upstate New York.

Interested?

YES! Magazine encourages you to make free use of this article by taking these easy steps. Hayes, S. (2010, September 08). Movies, My Kids, and Me. Retrieved February 03, 2012, from YES! Magazine Web site: http://www.yesmagazine.org/blogs/shannon-hayes/movies-my-kids-and-me. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License Creative Commons License


You won’t see any commercial ads in YES!, in print or on this website.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.

||   SUBSCRIBE    ||   GIVE A GIFT   ||   DONATE   ||
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.




Reader Comments

what a lovely article!

Posted by Anna Parr at Sep 10, 2010 11:32 AM
thanks for sharing that marvelous image of your daughters dancing under the moon with all of us readers out here. what a treasure. i had a similar (albeit far less lovely) experience with my kids this summer. we have moved recently, can't sell our house for anything, are renting an apartment in the meantime, and living on air mattresses because all of our beds are busy making our non-selling house look staged and lovely. one of the mattresses sprung a leak, and i was feeling pretty sorry for myself and my new nightly routine of blowing up the air mattress before bed. then one night my kids happened to be on top of the mattress. they went nuts when they felt themselves lifting off the ground as the mattress filled with air. the sheer joy in their laughter was absolutely a memory i will take to my grave. my husband and i just laughed and completely enjoyed that moment. we even started letting the bed collapse on purpose so we could blow it up again. i don't feel sorry for myself and my mattress routine anymore. :)

Yes!

Posted by Crystal at Sep 14, 2010 07:48 AM
Yeah!!! This is exactly what I needed to read this morning! My final pep talk to pull the plug!! I enthusiastically read your book over the summer Shannon, but I have never visited any of your posts on the web, until today... and I think fate brought me to you again, because my husband and I were deeply debating the removal of our last TV in the house this morning. My youngest (3) has started asking for a "show" the minute he wakes, and it's been driving me nuts! My kids don't watch TV at all, and I was trying to convince myself that videos were harmless, even though I felt this nagging inside that the only person I was helping out was myself (free time!!)
Thank you for this post, I'm pulling that final plug right now! (God help me!)

Be strong!!

Posted by Shannon at Sep 15, 2010 09:01 AM
Great comments, both of you. Anna, I am all for minimalist living, but kudos to you for surviving on an air mattress...I admire your ability to find the joy in it. And Crystal, so glad you were inspired. The funny thing about the whole movie ordeal is that, while I noticed that it seemed to buy time/space for us grown-ups, there was actualyl a big time investment in "re-acclimating" the kids to the family the minute the screen was turned off. We've definitely had some tough moments when Bob and I have been tempted to turn it back on, but we both now feel very strongly that it has been for the better. But hold strong during the weak moments....because if you break down then, then they know you're breakable! ;-)


TV

Posted by Jen at Sep 15, 2010 12:01 PM
Maybe I didn't read this correctly but you seem to imply that your kids have a TV in their bedroom.

BIG MISTAKE!

It is unnecessary, isolating, and ultimately a source of problems.

You may need to make another sacrifice and do away with the convenience (yours) of their personal boob tube.

entertaining thought

Posted by Jen Burton at Sep 15, 2010 01:52 PM
Shannon,

I don't have kids, but your article made me think about my own enjoyment of films, and the frequency with which real life brings to mind movie scenes, quotes, song lyrics, ... To what extent might my own path mirror that of your kids, as industrial entertainment infiltrated their minds? Thanks for inspiring thought, in this and other articles. I look forward to more.

Jen

TV and only child

Posted by Carla at Sep 19, 2010 09:56 AM
We have fallen prey to the lazy out of allowing our child to watch movies. We do not have TV service nor does she have a TV in her room. Without the respite of movies, I would need to be her playmate. How has any one else handled this?

no more shows

Posted by Jess at Jul 06, 2011 03:14 PM
Shannon, thank you for this article! My almost-3 year old watches "shows" on netflix. He usually watches no more than 30 minutes a day, and we slowly worked up to that. I was hesitant to let him watch so much, but like you said, it gave me a much needed break. Now I'm realizing how over-stimulating it is, and how difficult it is to re-acclimate him after the show is over. We've spent the past few days without any shows, and today he didn't ask at all (big change!). We're spending more time together, playing, and he's helping more in what ways he can. I'm loving it! I feel more connected, and his behavior is so much better, probably b/c he feels more connected as well. I loved reading your account of pulling the plug on shows.

eeee!

Posted by jennyg at Jul 18, 2011 08:09 AM
!! made me tear up. thanks for this. most convincing argument i've read for night of moon, versus nights of movie.

People Who Love YES! Find Out Why... Subscribe Today

Personal tools