For Thriving Public Spaces, Just Add Seating
William H. Whyte was a journalist who spent years observing how people act and interact in public spaces. He walked the streets, sat with notebook in plazas and parks, set up cameras in unobtrusive places, and spent endless hours studying the results.
He noticed that when people stop to chat on sidewalks they don’t move to an edge or entryway, they stay right in the middle. Others have to walk around them. In plazas, they tend to congregate where other people are. Even lovers don’t seek the solitude of secluded corners, as one might expect. They coo right out in the open, for all to see.“It is difficult to design a space that will not attract people,” Whyte wrote. “What attracts people most is other people.”
And yet, remarkably, many cities have succeeded in designing “under-crowded” public spaces, sometimes very grand and beautiful ones. The reason, Whyte found, is that people don’t care about the architectural design of a public space. What they do care about is one simple thing: places to sit. They especially like steps and ledges, perhaps because they don’t appear intended for sitting. And they like chairs they can move around, so they can create their own groups or sit apart and read.
Which brings me to a vacant—that is, undeveloped—lot on Main Street in my town, right next to a gift shop and a bakery. The bakery has a couple of benches outside, and in the mornings the place is buzzing. More than one person has noted that the adjacent vacant lot would make a natural extension of it. There could be more benches, some tables for eating or for chess, maybe a play area for little kids. It could be the heart of town.
A friend and I decided to see if we could make a commons happen there just by seeding it a bit. We both had old garden benches lying around, so we fixed them up and painted them. Then we deposited them without ceremony on the lot, added a bunch of tree stumps, and waited.
Without any marketing or hype, people quickly started using the benches, talking and sipping or just resting their feet. Lo and behold, this ad hoc commons produced not a tragedy but rather a comedy, in the root sense of that word.
Part of the hidden narrative of a commons is the rewards it gives to those who make it better.
I was hoping for something like that. What I didn’t anticipate was how good I’d feel. The people sitting there don’t know where the benches came from, but I do. My son, who helped me paint them, feels great pride as well. Part of the hidden narrative of a commons is the rewards it gives to those who make it better.
What makes this “commons” possible is that the private owner of the lot is an older man who lives about twenty miles away and for whatever reason has been happy to let the lot sit empty. Lately we heard that the owner has gone into a home, which raises concerns about the heirs.
Will the property fall to the son or daughter with an MBA who will look at the family inventory and see—horrors!—an underperforming asset? Will the lot be sold to conform to the strict code of economically correct behavior, or to appease a petulant sibling?
We are discussing contingency plans. But meanwhile it is clear that the threat to our commons is not the inherent “tragedy” of it, but rather the tragedy that might arise from profit-maximizing ownership of it.
Editor’s note: The vacant lot on Main Street in Point Reyes Station has now been formally leased by West Marin Commons. It has become the de facto town commons and is informally known as Jon Rowe Park.
Based on the book Our Common Wealth: The Hidden Economy That Makes Everything Else Work, Copyright © 2013 by Jonathan Rowe. Reprinted with permission of , San Francisco, CA. ]www.bkconnection.com or 800-929-2929.
Jonathan Rowe is a former contributing editor to YES! Magazine and Washington Monthly. He co-founded the organization On The Commons, which promotes commons-based solutions to problems. He was also the founder and co-director of the West Marin Commons, which works to create spaces for spontaneous sociability and also an infrastructure for sharing knowledge and resources on the western edge of Marin County, Calif. Rowe passed away in March, 2011.
- Jonathan Rowe, 1946-2011
In memory of a longtime YES! Magazine contributor.
- How Commerce Consumed the Commons
In a world where everything's for sale, we've forgotten that much of value happens outside the stream of commerce. Here's how we forgot--and how we're reclaiming the commons.
- Photo Essay: 20 of the World's Best Public Spaces
Public spaces can be anything from a lush urban park to a subway station, but all of them offer a free place to enjoy the company of friends, family, and strangers.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.