Give Gifts Top Banner

Home » People Power » Infographic: The Math Error Behind 30 Years of Education Policy

Get a FREE Issue. Yes! I want to try YES! Magazine

Nonprofit. Independent. Subscriber-supported. DONATE. How you can support our work.

YES! by Email
Join over 78,000 others already signed up for FREE YES! news.

The YES! ChicoBag(R). Full-size tote that fits in your pocket!


Infographic: The Math Error Behind 30 Years of Education Policy

An influential study's failure to consider factors like poverty, race, and immigration concealed the fact that scores were improving.
Document Actions

The push to reform America’s failing schools dates to the Reagan administration’s 1983 report, “A Nation at Risk,” which found that U.S. students’ test scores were plummeting. That news was so startling that Reagan’s energy secretary, Admiral James Watkins, commissioned the Sandia National Laboratory to find out why. What Sandia found (in a report not published until 1993) was even more startling: Although the overall average score had gone down, scores had gone up in each demographic group. How’s that work?

Across the board, scores had gone up.

For starters, it’s established that less-advantaged children, whether poorer, or members of a disfavored minority, or recent immigrants, score lower on standardized tests.

In the period of time covered by “A Nation at Risk,” the number of disadvantaged students had increased much faster than the number of more advantaged ones. During that time, scores for each group had gone up. Schools and teachers were succeeding.

Here’s an illustration of how the math works:

1,000 students take a standardized test. They are evenly split among income groups, and the richer students score better than the poorer ones. Later, 1,000 students take the same test. In between, the demographics have shifted. Across the board, scores have gone up. But because there are so many more low-income students than there used to be, the overall average goes down. This is exactly what the Sandia report said had happened in the United States.

“A Nation at Risk” didn’t prove that schools were failing. It proved that the study’s authors failed math.

Doug Pibel New 2012Doug Pibel wrote this article for Education Uprising, the Spring 2014 issue of YES! Magazine. Doug is managing editor of YES!

More Stories

Email Signup
Comment on this article

How to add a commentCommenting Policy

comments powered by Disqus

You won’t see any commercial ads in YES!, in print or on this website.
That means, we rely on support from our readers.

||   SUBSCRIBE    ||   GIVE A GIFT   ||   DONATE   ||
Independent. Nonprofit. Subscriber-supported.

Issue Footer

Personal tools